Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #1.4 Review: The Bogenrieder Perspective


“It’s been altered beyond recognition.”

Well, let’s see, Batman v. Superman came out, but nobody else is talking about Amazing Spider-Man 1.4…   And reviewing Spider-Man comics is my job on this site…. Hello, darkness, my old friend…..ASMPO2015004-DC21-4fcd6

Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #1.4

“Amazing Grace, Pt. 4: Within the Veil”

Writer: Jose Molina

Pencils: Simone Blanchi and Andrea Broccardo

Inks: Simone Blanchi and Andrea Broccardo

Colors: David Curiel

Editor: Nick Lowe and Devon Lewis

Plot:  

Hey, y’all remember that one issue last month, where Julio Rodriguez killed an old man? Turns out that was his dad. (Because Comic) Spidey and the Santerians meet up, confirm that Julio isn’t human (Wouldn’t have realized that) and they fight. (Because we’re now in the 80s, you see) Spidey ducks out and runs away and he
and Anna Maria go off and follow Julio around a shopping mall. He then cures a little girl of her blindness (That’s a sentence I just said!) and they see the guy who killed Julio. Spidey hangs him over a building (You know, for kids! Then again, Spectacular did it, so…) and finds out that Julio committed suicide and set everything up. (Pretty damn elaborate plan) And so our comic ends with the Santerians deciding to ask Spider-Man for more help.

Thoughts:

…..

….. I’ve got nothing.

After viewing such notable cult classic Christploitation films such as War Room, Kirk Cameron’s Saving Christmas, and God’s Not Dead 1 and 2 in the past few weeks, I think I have found something far worse. Is that even possible?!ASMPO2015004-int3-1-9d1ad

We’re reviewing Amazing Spider-Man. Of course it’s possible.

I think we should start off with the art. It’s atrocious. I praised it last three issues as the saving grace of the point one divergence, but here it fails on all levels. When they change perspectives, you can’t tell who the characters are. It’s also worth noting that they added another artist to this issue for a flashback scene, and it’s really jarringly noticeable. They also didn’t get this second artist an inker, so they let her do her own inks. And it’s even worse than Blanchi’s inks.

I think the worst problem of this comic is that it’s so bad in the sense that you can’t make fun of this. I like to compare this to the “Temple of Doom vs. Kingdom of the Crystal Skull” argument. I like to think that Temple of Doom is better in that it’s at least memorably bad, in a manner similar to other so-weird-it’s great films like Birdemic, The Room and Cool Cat Saves the Kids. At the same time, it surpasses Kingdom of the Crystal Skull because KotCS is so forgettable that it’s not worth anything even if it is okay. This comic is so bad that it isn’t even funny, and for a comic, pure bad is never a good thing.

But the absolute worst moment of this whole arc comes up when Peter blames God for not saving his Uncle in a flashback. What I find perplexing about this is that it ultimately undermines Peter’s mantra of “With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility”. Peter’s guilt complex is fueled by his inability to save his uncle, and to continue fighting evil in the world with his powers instead of abusing them. With these five panels, Peter, for some reason, decides to shift his blame to somebody else, which makes about fifty years of comics apparently meaningless; without blame to inflict on himself, he therefore would have no reason to fight crime. So, in about one page, Peter is ultimately ripped of his core character trait and stripped of any redeeming qualities.

By the time I finished reading this comic, I had already considering going outside, lighting it on fire, and running it over with my car in the rain for extra measure. It was so bad and took so much away from the character that I’m left with the cynical impression that we will never get a Spider-Man that is true to character for next few decades.

Because it so bad even an F can’t describe it….

Final Grade: Potato (This comic broke me, by the way)

Liked it? Take a second to support the Crawlspace on Patreon!