Amazing Spider-Man #57 (#498)
Happy Birthday Part-One
Writers: J. Michael Straczynski
Penciler: John Romita Jr.
Inker: Scott Hanna
PLOT: JMS is back on writing duties for Amazing Spider-Man. This is the first issue of a three-part story-arc, which will be concluded, in a historic issue #500. This book has a bit of everything. It begins with a hilarious interaction between Peter, his students, and the school administration. It leads to an interesting dinner conversation between Peter, Aunt May, and MJ about the nature of people. Peter and MJ are a lot more comfortable with each other, and there is red lightening. Yup, red lightening. While in bed, Peter notices the weird lightening and knows that there is something amiss in New York City. He quickly suits up and scurries off to see an awesome display of Earth’s mightiest heroes try to push back an army of The Mindless Ones.
Peter joins in on the battle, but even the heroes continue to have great difficulty with the sheer numbers of these transdimensional creatures. Reed Richards comes to the battle scene with a plan to send these creatures back to the dimension they came from. With the help of his machine, and the powers of all the heroes, they zap the creatures into a black hole. Once that is done, a worried Doctor Strange comes in and informs them that they have made a grave mistake. They have in fact brought back the dreaded villain known as Dormammu.
LIKES: What remarkable book. It’s been along time since I read something this entertaining. Peter’s interactions with his supporting characters were good to see, especially his continued relationship with MJ. But the battle scene against The Mindless Ones was truly remarkable, especially when accompanied by JRjr’s art. The two page spread introducing Spider-Man to the battle was awesome, as well as the final page featuring Dormammu. I’m very excited about the next issue coming out.
DISLIKES: First, I thought we were told that Ezekiel would play an important part in these next three issues, but he was nowhere to be seen. Also, this book felt like a crossover issue rather than a Spider-Man issue with all these Marvel heroes involved, and even though I like Dormammu, I hope he is not the main villain Spidey will be facing in issue #500. Hes more of a Doctor Strange villain rather than a Spider-Man villain. I would personally prefer a new bad guy than him. One last thing, Thor did not look like the Thor that we are used to seeing in the books, and what the heck is a shirt and tie Cyclops doing in the middle of all this?
RATING: 4 and 1/2 webheads out of 5. Well, we definitely got started off with bang towards the road to Amazing Spider-Man #500. I can’t wait to see what the heck Dormammu has to do with Spider-Man.
Reviewed by AC-WEB (Ariel Chaidez)
Adam Schingle
View articlesLifelong fan of Spider-Man. My secret identity is Adam S.
You might be interested in …
Alford Notes: ASM #29/830
by Mark Alford
The current arc has all sorts of questions hanging over it – will Aunt May win her battle with cancer? How will F.E.A.S.T. become a part of the new continuity? Is Peter ever going to […]
Alford Notes: Amazing Spider-Man #5
by Mark Alford
Tombstone got the best of Spidey. Will he just take it? Find a way to strike back? Or worse – get his butt handed to him all over again? You know one way or the […]
Amazing Spider-man 11/812-12/813 Review
by ryan3178
I review the first two parts of the J. Jonah Jameson story line from Amazing Spider-man #11/812-12/813. Enjoying the character work and artwork, I give the story a medium grade. Still well put together, but […]
Crawlspace Discord

Social
Recent Comments
Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #29 (Legacy #993): “Spore, Huh, Yeah, What Is He Good For? Absolutely Nothing, Say It Again, Y’all!”: “@Evan Berry: “Sha-la-la-laa!” What would we do baby … with out us? “Remember when Peter learned the ‘Way of the…” May 26, 18:24
Evan Berry on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #29 (Legacy #993): “Spore, Huh, Yeah, What Is He Good For? Absolutely Nothing, Say It Again, Y’all!”: “@Hornacek — Sha-la-la-laa! Remember when Peter learned the “Way of the Spider” from Shang-Chi? That’s what the training with Daredevil…” May 26, 13:00
Comet Omelette on Spider-Tracer: Top Ten Spider-Man Characters Co-Created by Gerry Conway: “I have a soft spot for the Tarantula.” May 25, 11:08
Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #29 (Legacy #993): “Spore, Huh, Yeah, What Is He Good For? Absolutely Nothing, Say It Again, Y’all!”: “@Aqu@: “Maybe I’m missing context, but since when Peter needs to train his spidersense with Daredevil?” Spidey was defeated by…” May 22, 06:13
Aqu@ on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #29 (Legacy #993): “Spore, Huh, Yeah, What Is He Good For? Absolutely Nothing, Say It Again, Y’all!”: “I skimmed the review to see where we’re at with ASM nowadays, without spoiling myself too much since I’m still…” May 22, 05:52
Treyvon Williams on MARCO SPEAKS SPIDEY: Spectacular Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026) #1 Review: “This was a decent Spider-Man story. It mainly retells us about past events that have happened over the past years…” May 20, 22:10
Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #27 (Legacy #991): “The Real Torment Was The Ending” or “MJ Lets Torment Go”: “@Jack: RIP Paul.” May 20, 01:40
Brad Douglas on New Marvel Legends Spider-Man 67 and Future Foundation Figures Revealed!: “Sold!!!” May 19, 23:18
Evan Berry on New Marvel Legends Spider-Man 67 and Future Foundation Figures Revealed!: “I think that the hope is that people will buy more than one so that they can re-create the meme!…” May 19, 07:26
Jack on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #27 (Legacy #991): “The Real Torment Was The Ending” or “MJ Lets Torment Go”: “Hi everybody. Three years ago, I had a heart attack and a stroke. I’ve had lots of therapy. I’m feeling…” May 19, 04:51

