Amazing Spider-Man #29
PLOT: For no reason whatsoever Peter is again totally convinced Mary Jane is alive. We finally get to see who is holding her: some nut case who hears everyone else’s thoughts. He explains to MJ that ever since Spidey saved him from falling debris during a Spidey/Goblin fight he formed some kind of link with Peter . He not only knows everything about Peter’s life but can experience everything Peter does. He then explains to MJ that he drugged her with a lollipop and in disguise removed her from the ill-fated airplane as she appeared to be sick. Probably due to their “link” Spidey is drawn to the hideaway where he finds MJ and is ambushed by the wacko.
LIKES: MJ’s back! MJ’s back! MJ’s back! Lee Weeks subs for John Romita, Jr. on pencils here and does a nice job as Joe Bennet did last issue. This is Mackie’s last issue! This is Mackie’s last issue!
DISLIKES: If this was issue 15 or 16 and if there was any foreshadowing at all you might have the making of a pretty good story arc here. However, the stalker/kidnapper comes out of nowhere. We were never given an inkling of his existence. He’s essentially a character who prior to this was a mysterious blank slate who disappeared for about 15 issues. This leaves us with the suspicion that Mackie had nothing planned when the stalker storyline began and only now, bowing to pressure to bring MJ back, made up this part. After all the trouble and issues with Peter accepting MJ’s death he now mysteriously becomes convinced she’s alive again. Talk about rendering the bulk of over a year’s worth of stories irrelevant. Will we ever find out what was in the box that convinced Peter MJ was dead? What kind of lame reason will Mackie come up with to explain why MJ had to be held captive for so long? Will he sluff that off on poor Paul Jenkins.
RATING: ![]()
web-heads out of 4: would be much higher if there was any decent foreshadowing and the story came about 10 issues ago.
HB 56
View articlesYou might be interested in …
The Amazing Spider-Man #677 Review
A review in which familiar readers will not be surprised.
Read’s Reads Amazing Spider-Man #22 and Lost Hunt #5 Review
by ryan3178
Before I depart for Spring Break, I review part two of “What did Peter Do? and the conclusion to Lost Hunt. While we get some answers, this should have been more of: “What did Paul […]
Amazing Spider-Man (Vol. 1) #541 Review
by Chris Linas
The Amazing Spider-Man #541 Title: “Back in Black” Part 3 of 5 Writer: J. Michael Straczynski Penciler: Ron Garney Inker: Bill Reinhold Colorist: Mat Milla Plot: Peter lets the incarcerated Kingpin know he’s coming for […]
Crawlspace Discord

Social
Recent Comments
Dark Mark on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “Yeah, this is about a Peter & Eddie things because Torment is acting on Carnage’s information. That’s why it is…” Mar 10, 06:04
Evan Berry on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “@Hornacek – In my mind, I guess I was thinking of the Terminator going after anyone named Sarah Connor. It…” Mar 9, 08:39
Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “@Evan Berry: I didn’t catch onto the last names of the victims until about halfway through that issue so once…” Mar 8, 09:30
Evan Berry on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “@Hornacek — Thanks, Craig! I completely forgot about Eddie’s wife. I guess I can’t feel too bad for that. I…” Mar 7, 16:07
Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “@DarkMark: I would be more upset about Shocker’s death if we hadn’t already gone through Boomerang’s meaningful death and then…” Mar 7, 06:39
Dark Mark on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “The story is well done, but just not for me. I am glad that Peter and MJ are talking and…” Mar 6, 16:05
Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “Anne Weying is the name of Eddie’s (deceased) ex-wife. “Anaconda consumes local resident Francine Weylin, 72”. It’s on the page…” Mar 5, 14:41
Evan Berry on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #23 (Legacy #987): “CARNAGE KNOWS”: “@Hornacek — I have a question: I may be missing something, because when I saw that you had written the…” Mar 5, 13:01
ryan3178 on Read’s Reads Amazing Spider-Man/Venom Death Spiral #1 Review: “It’s kind of like the Guardians Lite are mentioned but everything with Hellgate accept for a passing talk in Amazing…” Mar 4, 17:53

