Amazing Spider-Man 38
PLOT: Aunt May confronts Peter about her discovery that he is Spider-Man.
LIKES: This issue strikes all the right chords. The sequence of Peter imagining the different possibilities of what May wants to talk about is great. Their talk, which takes up practically the whole issue, is a classic. It rings true emotionally. May’s focusing more on the fact that Peter has lied to her over a long period of time than on the fact of him being Spider-Man forces him to come clean. Her show of strenght also allows Peter to admit the truth. Their swapping stories about Uncle Ben’s murder is particularly powerful. In this one issue JMS has made May a more substantial and rounded character than at any time in the nearly 40 years of Spider-Man.
DISLIKES: Although it does get a slight mention I think Spider-Man’s bad reputation and May’s life long fear of him should have been a bigger point of eontention during their talk. Is JMS relying on an origin other than Lee and Ditko’s? In Spider-Man Vol. 1, No. 1(not Amazing Fantasy 15, I checked) Ben is clearly shot in the house in view of May. Here May says he went for a walk and was killed.
RATING: 4 of 5 webheads: 1 point is lost for glossing over Spider-Man’s image as a quasi-criminal and for the twist from the original origin. Otherwise a very strong issue.
HB 56
View articlesYou might be interested in …
Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #48 (Legacy #942): “The Doctor Will See You Now” or “The (Henry) Winkler Device Returns”
by Hornacek
A therapy session … with Queen Goblin? Chasm, Hallows’ Eve, and Queen Goblin versus … a competent Spider-Man? And the day is saved by … Betty Brant??? Plus the Sinister Six’s plan is revealed and […]
Alford Notes: Amazing Spider-Man #76
by Mark Alford
Let’s go, gang! Three weeks in a row with new Spider-Man content! I’m excited! Read on and find out why and whats going on with our favorite webhead and that other guy! Credit Where Credit […]
Amazing Spider-Man #798- Peter and Norman’s Excellent Adventure, Pt 2
“This is perfect. Everything is the way it should be.” Can Slott keep up the forward momentum he gained from part one of Go Down Swinging? Find out here, Crawlspacers! Amazing Spider-Man #798 “Go Down […]
Social
Recent Comments
- Evan Berry on Panel(s) of the Day #1548: “And tomorrow it’ll be the 17th anniversary of the release of Spider-man 3.” May 3, 10:47
- Jeff Walling on The Chi✶Town Breakdown: USM #4 (2024): “I loved the issue – one thing that stuck out to me was how oily MJs hair looked in the…” May 2, 15:42
- Hornacek on The Chi✶Town Breakdown: USM #4 (2024): “@Evan – I went back and saw the “stain”. To me it just looks like a shadow or smudge -…” May 1, 15:58
- Evan Berry on The Chi✶Town Breakdown: USM #4 (2024): “@Chi-Town — It’s probably just a design choice, and I’m thinking too hard. 😀” May 1, 15:55
- Chi-Town Spidey on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #48 (Legacy #942): “The Doctor Will See You Now” or “The (Henry) Winkler Device Returns”: “*checks in* Yep, ASM still sucks…I’m glad Hornacek is covering reviews, otherwise we have to listen to Mark wine.” May 1, 15:04
- Chi-Town Spidey on The Chi✶Town Breakdown: USM #4 (2024): “Hornacek: Who do you think TAUGHT that to Mark? That’s why he calls me his “best friend”. Evan: Honestly, never…” May 1, 15:00
- Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #46 (Legacy #940): “The Ravencroft Redemption” or “Anna Watson, Villain Rehabilitator”: “@Evan Berry: A two-parter makes more sense – a 1980s sitcom would not likely have a subplot going on for…” May 1, 13:49
- Hornacek on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #48 (Legacy #942): “The Doctor Will See You Now” or “The (Henry) Winkler Device Returns”: “@Aqu@: “IMO, the ‘behind the scene’ bit was in bad taste; it’s also unnecessary, since actions tell more than words.…” May 1, 13:42
- Aqu@ on Craig’s Critique: Amazing Spider-Man #48 (Legacy #942): “The Doctor Will See You Now” or “The (Henry) Winkler Device Returns”: “IMO, the “behind the scene” bit was in bad taste; it’s also unnecessary, since actions tell more than words. It…” May 1, 11:55
- Evan Berry on The Chi✶Town Breakdown: USM #4 (2024): “Sort of a nitpicky question, but what’s with the stain on Gwen’s right elbow in that panel with her introduction?…” Apr 30, 18:32